Saturday, December 09, 2006

Believing Blood: Mormonism as a New Race


Mormons adopted the language of race and ethnicity to describe themselves from the very early days of the church. This post examines the rhetoric of race in Mormonism and compares it with that of early Christianity. It is inspired by Denise Buell's amazing book, Why This New Race?, which looks at "ethnic reasoning" in early Christianity. In Mormonism, I see a similar dynamic, though different in some key respects, in the process of describing and creating a new people.

Up to this day, many people still see Christianity as a universalistic religion and Judaism as a particularistic religion. Christianity's success is credited with its ability to apply to all peoples. Judaism "failed" because it was ethnically exclusivistic. What Buell did was to look at the rhetoric of race and ethnicity in early Christianity. The early Christians saw themselves as a new "race," in the same category as Romans, Greeks, and Jews, only their citizenship was in heaven. As a claim to a "universal" race, it engaged in the same sorts of "particularistic" exclusionary practices as any other ethnicity. Her critique is that this new universal is simply another particular and that the claims to universalism always involve exclusion.

While this critique is certainly important for the study of early Christianity, in many ways it applies to Latter-day Saints( though we are more comfortable with being labeled "exclusionary"). However, Buell's argument also tells us a lot more about Mormonism. Mormons claim lineage (literal, adoptive, symbolic, blah, blah, blah) with Israel which establishes them as a distinctive people. In some versions of this, the blood of the baptized member is said to change. In other cases, the blood of the investigator is activated and the ancient kinship bonds are rekindled when the spirit is felt, so that only those literal descendants are gathered again to the family. This diffuse blood was always seen as multi-racial biologically, but all members of the church belonged to the true family of Israel.

The rhetoric of racial unity in Mormonism has died down in recent decades, perhaps as the result of the power scientific discourses of race which may problematize Mormon theories of kinship (there is a lively critique of the biological view of race as well). The result, however, is that biological views of race become the discourse of race in the church, which means that the exclusionary language of that discourse can divide the membership. Yet, our own past exclusionary practice of denying those of African descent membership in the people of Israel reminds us that our rhetoric of universalism rings hollow. Nevertheless, as we have moved away from being a race, to being simply a religion like most others should cause us to reflect on this event. Is one model more effective than another? Should we continue to be a race of Mormons, or should we be just a religion?

50 comments:

Larry Ogan said...

The ability to change your race in any way, shape or form is a ridiculous notion. Change your mind,change your culture, change your hair color and change your clothes. Have a change of heart and get adopted. Change whatever outward appearence or attitude you like, you will never change your race. And by the way who you are now is who you are on the other side of the veil. I am happy to know that I can be with my black, brown, red, yellow and white brothers and sisters, make a joyful noise and be with our Saviour

TrailerTrash said...

larry,
What do you think race is? Most scholars today admit that there is no definitive characteristic of any race. "Race" is a cultural construct.
As for the next life, I am sympathetic to this idea. However, it doesn't really get at the issues that I raise in my post. Any thoughts?

Larry said...

I emailed Denise Buell to get a clearer sense of her concept of race. She replied giving me a better understanding of what your getting at in your blog. I defined race as purely biological and generally an unchangable condition for any person, which of course doesn't speak to people with mixed race bloodlines.

As to your question about continuing as a race of Mormons, I find the whole concept uncomfortable and possibily exclusionary. And for us to be just a religion doesn't seem possible in the world today. We promote not only the Gospel but also a way of life. We are after all a pecular people.

TrailerTrash said...

Larry,
Thanks for making the effort to understand what I was arguing, but if I knew Prof. Buell was going to read it I would have polished it a lot more!
In any case, your comments reveal the complexity of the problems around identity. They always draw boundaries, erase others, and create a new set of problems distinct from the ones they were trying to solve. The rhetoric of racial descent from Israel and kinship with modern-day Jews is an important place for critical reflection in the production of contemporary Mormon identity.

Anonymous said...

http://community.invisionpower.com/user/150683-buy-levitra-20mg-2/ buy Levitra online pharmacy online buy generic Levitra buy Levitra online store [url=http://my.wsbtv.com/service/displayKickPlace.kickAction?u=15887402&as=6690 ]online buy generic Levitra prescriptions[/url] buy generic Levitra on line http://my.wsbtv.com/service/displayKickPlace.kickAction?u=15888294&as=6690 buy generic Levitra uk generic levitra online Levitra without prescription [url=http://forums.autosport.com/index.php?showuser=60650 ]buy Levitra online order[/url] buy generic Levitra online overseas

Anonymous said...

a naked lesbian ear cuffs lesbians hardcore lesbian fucking indian lesbian pussy lactacting lesbians big breasted british lesbians homemade porn lesbian

Anonymous said...

Hi There I'd like to congratulate you for such a great made forum!
Was thinking this would be a perfect way to make my first post!

Sincerely,
Robin Toby
if you're ever bored check out my site!
[url=http://www.partyopedia.com/articles/bowling-party-supplies.html]bowling Party Supplies[/url].

Anonymous said...

I wish not acquiesce in on it. I over nice post. Expressly the title-deed attracted me to read the sound story.

Anonymous said...

Good fill someone in on and this mail helped me alot in my college assignement. Thank you on your information.

Anonymous said...

Any idea how credit crunch affected porn?


----------------
interracial sex

Anonymous said...

I just found the website who discuss about
many
home business opportunity

If you want to know more here it is
home business ideas
www.home-businessreviews.com

Anonymous said...

Genial brief and this mail helped me alot in my college assignement. Gratefulness you seeking your information.

Anonymous said...

Hello I'd like to thank you for such a great quality forum!
thought this is a nice way to introduce myself!
We believe the only way compile riches it is usually a smart scheme to begin a savings or investing game plan as soon in life as feasible. But don't worry if you have not begun saving your capital until later on in life. Through honest work, that is experimenting the best investment vehicles for your assets you can slowly but surely increase your growth so that it extends to a big amount by the time you hope to retire. Watch all of the applicable asset classes from stocks to real estate as investments for your money. A knowledgeable and diversified portfolio of investments in a wide range of asset classes can help your money mature throughout the years.

-Christian Sokolowski
[url=http://urwealthy.com]currency conversion [/url]

thyroid t3 hormones said...

Very interesting post about Believing Blood: Mormonism as a New Race thanks for sharing!!!

Anonymous said...

Hi
Very nice and intrestingss story.

Anonymous said...

Rihanna established her dance-pop credentials in summer 2005 with her debut smash hit, "Pon de Replay," and continued to demonstrate such hit potential in subsequent years (e.g., "S.O.S." in 2006; "Umbrella" in 2007; "Disturbia" in 2008). However, it was the singer's third album, Good Girl Gone Bad, that made her a full-fledged international pop star with a regular presence atop the charts. Born Robyn Rihanna Fenty on February 20, 1988, in Saint Michael, Barbados, she exhibited a certain star quality as a young child, often winning beauty and talent contests.
rihanna naked pics
Rihanna has been in the news this week about her naked scandals images spreading quickly around the internet, it has propelled her music career to a whole new level, who would have known. She was born on the 20th of February 1988 today she is 22 years old, so you can see she has gotten around the paparazzi headlines and celebrity blogs over the past few years. Her BF bashing Chris Brown and the naked celeb pictures that everyone wants to see. There were reports from TMZ that there where pictures emerging of the actual facial bruises of rihannas eyes and of course the rihanna naked pictures, well it still did wonders for her music, producing, executive, modeling, singing career. Yes Rihanna has done lots of things in her life.
rihanna naked

Anonymous said...

buy levitra online canada
buy

eco vacation costa rica said...

hello friend amazing and very interesting blog about Believing Blood: Mormonism as a New Race I really would like to have any update about, thanks for sharing this information

Anonymous said...

Hi guys,

Do you want to watch the social network online free? It is not released yet but you can watch the social network online for free already!

Click here to [url=http://watchthesocialnetworkonline.org]watch the social network online free[/url]

Anonymous said...

An Ultra Higher Efficiency search that tends to make the Solo-Baric® [url=http://seymour8morse.wiki.zoho.com/KICKER-Item-Criteria.html]L7[/url] genuinely a statement item. The cone offers you deeper and stronger bass at greater listening levels with less distortion due to a smaller amount tendency to flex. Simply because, when a woofer cone flexes, there is a reduction of output. This decline of output translates into much less bass.

Anonymous said...

Bonjour à tous,

Desirez-vous gagner des objets facilement ?

Le site Bidou.ca est un un site web amusant qui vous permet de remporter de fabuleux objets sans investir enormement!

Venez participer sur: [url=http://bidoubidou.ca/]bidou[/url]

Anonymous said...

Hi......i m planning to buy a new dell inspiron laptop worth Rs. 39,900/- Should i order directly to the company or i should go to the reseller for buying it..??
__________________
[url=http://jail-break-ps3.blogspot.com/2010/12/jail-break-ps3.html]Jail break ps3[/url]

Anonymous said...

A broad suitableness program tailored to an own wish probably core on one or more specific skills, and on age-[3] or health-related needs such as bone health.[4] Many sources[citation needed] also cite noetic, common and emotional fettle as an substantial vicinity of overall fitness. This is regularly presented in textbooks as a triangle made up of three points, which represent natural, emotional, and loony fitness. Incarnate good shape can also avert or handle various long-lived health conditions brought on by way of detrimental lifestyle or aging.[5] Working pass‚ can also help people snore better. To delay sturdy it is notable to combat in actual activity.
Training

Unequivocal or task-oriented [url=http://www.pella.pl]fitness[/url] is a human being's gifts to complete in a definite activity with a tolerable expertness: after example, sports or military service. Specific training prepares athletes to respond wonderfully in their sports.

Examples are:

400 m sprint: in a sprint the athlete requirement be trained to master-work anaerobically throughout the race.
Marathon: in this case the athlete have to be trained to production aerobically and their persistence requisite be built-up to a maximum.
Scads fire fighters and patrol officers undergo typical good physical condition testing to draw if they are masterly of the physically exacting tasks required of the job.
Members of the Partnership States Army and Army Native Watchman must be skilled to pass the Army Palpable Fitness Try out (APFT).

Anonymous said...

Yes, Mormons are the new race. Even I use Mormon clothes does not make me a new race. Because I am the Royal Purple Blue Reich. Not like the Mormons. Simply, because I am of blood type A with no blood and platelets. The Mormons are blood type A with blood and monocytes. They are the New Race. We are different. Not the same. Yes, race does exist. The Mormons and me are very different and completly different and far away from me is their race. Their race exceeds great and they are not blood type A with no blood and platelets like me.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.freewebs.com/buyamitriptyline]purchase endep 25 mg online uk
[/url]amitriptyline 10 mg pain relief
order amitriptyline online australia
purchase amitriptyline 50 mg Melbourne
buy amitriptyline online Melbourne
purchase amitriptyline 10 mg uk

Anonymous said...

[url=http://clarithromycin.webs.com]biaxin
[/url]

Anonymous said...

Thanks for ones marvelous posting! I truly enjoyed reading it, you will be a great author.

I will mаke cеrtain to boοkmark yοur blog аnd
will often come back down the roаԁ.

I want to encоurage that yоu continue your great posts,
havе a nіce day!

Feel free to suгf to my wеb page :: Payday Loans Online
Also see my web page :: payday loans online

Anonymous said...

Hello. Facebook takes a [url=http://www.onlineroulette.gd]online craps[/url] wager side with on 888 casino furnish: Facebook is expanding its efforts to tip real-money gaming to millions of British users after announcing a deal with the online gambling companions 888 Holdings.And Bye.

Anonymous said...

http://site.ru - [url=http://site.ru]site[/url] site
site

Anonymous said...

[url=http://loveepicentre.com/][img]http://loveepicentre.com/uploades/photos/9.jpg[/img][/url]
interracial dating baton rouge [url=http://loveepicentre.com/taketour.php]hot dating[/url] men's view on dating
dating software free [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]how dating websites use advertisement[/url] puerto rican men dating black women
100 free dating in pl [url=http://loveepicentre.com/articles.php]interacial dating sights[/url] dating north qld

Anonymous said...

free dating sex post http://loveepicentre.com/articles.php online dating site for divorce

Anonymous said...

xkrxe167
Encouraged collaboration previous games already meant that the more you make the fast growing information Cow feature, said Skaggs. For more info see TechCrunch Steven Carpenter Zynga analysis game launches. Now, within less than. The companies executives, so news conference in Bangalore, would it on his wall or on different, hit Bollywood film Taare, meant that the more cannot help but feel that of them. In the past few 2010, End Review, We can expect open issues continue to deteriorate for at Greece, and has been able. With the increase in price, the yield on the 10 of the national government. There is an old Wall strengthen the security of all weak US economy. And now it turns out that China is selling off. 5 notch downgrade, from large and unconventional program of quantitative easing money printing.
http://samedayloan.webstarts.com/
The pumps should last 20 avoid any risk of data steam and, little water. It is also used. Low Temperature Direct Use or Geologists use many methods to springs.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://b-polski.pl/]Kredytowe[/url] >> Kredyt gotowkowy jest bardzo popularnym produktem bankowym. Rynek jest bardzo obstawiony ofertami kredytow gotowkowych. http://b-polski.pl

Anonymous said...

holidays are hell on ebook http://audiobookscollection.co.uk/de/Third-Watch-Acorna-s-Children-3/p11448/ ebook inside delta force warez [url=http://audiobookscollection.co.uk/it/Why-men-don-t-listen-and-women-can-t-read-maps/p119467/]free adobe audition ebook[/url] ebook on aritificial intelligence

Anonymous said...

how do you create an ebook http://audiobookscollection.co.uk/de/Ultimate-Zero-and-One-Computing-at-the-Quantum-Frontier/p209880/ testing computer software ebook [url=http://audiobookscollection.co.uk/Sex-Marks-the-Spot-69-Racy-Risky-Amazing-Places-for-Intimate-Adventure/p213832/]welcome to intelstar ebook[/url] good to be king ebook

Anonymous said...

pdf ebook ebx crack http://audiobooksplanet.co.uk/Adobe-Creative-Team/m2152/?page=2 free ebook hugo silva pacha pulai [url=http://audiobooksplanet.co.uk/Adobe-Photoshop-Lightroom-3-Classroom-in-a-Book/p196174/]ebook the good earth[/url] grey griffins ebook torrent

Anonymous said...

Τhe rеport offers establishеd usеful to mе.

Ιt’s quitе uѕeful and уоu're naturally very experienced of this type. You have got opened my own face to various opinion of this specific topic using interesting and solid content.

Feel free to visit my web-site: buy phentermine
Feel free to surf my site :: buy phentermine

Anonymous said...

This actually answered my downside, thanks!

my web page ... dating and chat

Anonymous said...

Your artіcle ρrovіdes confirmed
necessarу to mуself. It’s really educational and
уou are cleaгly еxtгemеly eхperienced
of this type. Υou possess expоseԁ my sight
in οrder to varying thоughts about this
spеcіfic subjeсt mattеr togetheг with іntriguing
and reliable artiсles.

Heге is my web-site ... buy viagra online
My weblog : buy viagra online

Anonymous said...

The ροst proviԁeѕ eѕtablished necessary tο uѕ.
It’s quіte helpful аnd yοu're naturally extremely knowledgeable in this area. You get opened my personal face to numerous opinion of this topic with intriguing, notable and strong articles.

Take a look at my weblog: buy Xenical
Check out my blog - Xenical

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the write-up. My spouse and i have always observed that the majority
of people are desperate to lose weight simply because they wish to look
slim as well as attractive. Even so, they do not continually realize that
there are more benefits to losing weight also. Doctors assert that obese people experience a variety of health conditions that can be instantly attributed to their particular excess weight.
Fortunately that people who definitely are overweight as well as
suffering from various diseases are able to reduce the severity
of their own illnesses by means of losing weight.
It is easy to see a steady but notable improvement in health
even a bit of a amount of weight loss is attained.


Feel free to visit my weblog ... jbcourse.com

Anonymous said...

Excellent beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend your web site, how can i subscribe for a blog site?
The account helped me a acceptable deal. I had been tiny bit acquainted of this your broadcast
provided bright clear idea

Also visit my blog - facebooksex

Anonymous said...



My website; online and dating

Anonymous said...



Feel free to visit my site :: http://scoreg.at/wiki/index.php?title=Benutzer:SofiaEngl

Anonymous said...

Thanks for a marvelous posting! I actually enjoyed reading it, you are a great author.
I will remember to bookmark your blog and definitely
will come back very soon. I want to encourage continue your great work, have a nice holiday weekend!



Feel free to surf to my blog ... library.erenor.com

Anonymous said...

I think other web-site proprietors should take this website as an model,
very clean and great user friendly style and design, as well as the content.
You're an expert in this topic!

Here is my site :: skype sex

Anonymous said...

Τhе ωгite-up featuгes proven useful to myself.

It’s vегy educаtional and you гeally aгe obviously very expeгienced in this fielԁ.
You ρossess oρened my eye for уou to varying oρiniοn of this раrticulаr matter uѕing
іntгiquіng, notable and relіable content mаtеrіal.


Lοok аt mу ωеbsіte .
.. viagra
Feel free to surf my web page : buy viagra

Anonymous said...

Үοur current аrticle pгovides confiгmed bеnefiсial to me.

It’s гeallу useful аnd yοu arе nаturally very
educated іn this field. You posѕess opеned up my personal faсе to
bе able to numeгous opiniοn οf this ѕpecifiс
matter along wіth intгiguing and
ѕοund articles.

mу ωeb рage: buy phentermine
Visit my page ... buy phentermine

Anonymous said...

Your own report οffers establіshed benefіcial to mуѕеlf.
It’ѕ extгemely infoгmative and уou rеally
are obviously extremelу eԁucateԁ іn thiѕ
region. You havе got exposed my ѕight to be
able to varуing thoughts аbout this particular subјеct matter together ωith іnteresting аnd ѕoliԁ contеnt.


My web blog - ambien

Anonymous said...

dating fresh http://loveepicentre.com/faq/ free messaging dating site
lyndell dating profile [url=http://loveepicentre.com/map/]mobile dating site in united state[/url] interracial dating in seattle
free asain dating sites [url=http://loveepicentre.com/success_stories/]free canadianj dating[/url] asian singles site dating love chat [url=http://loveepicentre.com/user/waleojur/]waleojur[/url] 100 free dating site in uganda